Showing posts with label game balance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label game balance. Show all posts

Friday, October 8, 2010

Hero System 6th Edition – Key Changes

Last article I described the major changes in Hero System 6th edition, changes that were general in nature. This article I'm describing changes which are specific, but which are likely to affect many characters or come into play in many adventures, or otherwise are pretty likely to be noticed.

Key changes I feel improve the game:

Elemental Control is gone, replaced by the limitation "Unified Power". This is good, because Elemental Control was really just a random way to save points if you had certain specific powers and certain special effects, and clearly didn't belong within the logical Hero System framework, especially the 6th Edition view of that framework. The Unified Power limitation causes adjustment powers which affects one of your powers to affect all of your related powers. This seems like a very minor limitation (drains vs. specific powers are really rare), so Unified Power still looks like a random point break. But it is a much simpler, small rule, and is a more blatant point break, easily banned by the GM if necessary, so I think it is a great improvement. The one small advantage to Elemental Control was that it tended to give a point break to Energy Projectors, who were overpriced compared to Bricks and Martial Artists. But I think the other point cost changes in the system have already addressed this issue.

The rule that combat skill levels can be used to boost damage is now a general rule, not limited to hand-to-hand attacks in heroic campaigns. I've already been doing this for quite some time; it is more fun and not unbalancing.

The rules are clear that pushing can only be done in heroic situations, not just any time you have the extra END to spend. I've always used that rule in my games, I think this is was a fairly common interpretation. But the 4th Edition rules weren't really specific about this.

Sense-affecting powers (like Flash, Invisibility, and Darkness) are now much cheaper (usually half cost) when they only affect non-targeting senses (i.e. when they don't affect sight). This is great, making powers cheaper when they are less useful. Actually, the truth is that affecting non-targeting senses is usually far less than half as effective unless you have some sort of devious power combo; but half price is much better than full price!

There is a rule for untrained skill rolls! Previously, there was no real rule for what happens when you need to make a conversation check and you don't have the skill. This issue occurs in certain other game systems as well, and leads to a common problem. The general solution for the lack of a defined skill roll was that characteristic rolls be used. But characteristic rolls are quite high compared to the pitiful 8- roll for a familiarity in the skill. Unless the GM was really on top of this, it was all too easy for characters who were familiar with a skill to end up less capable than characters who were totally untrained, because the GM would say "make a driving roll" if the character had the skill, or "make a DEX roll" if he didn't. Even a DEX roll at -3 would be better than the 8- for a familiarity. With the new rules, an untrained character has 6-, fixing this problem. However, it does present a small trap for the unwary GM. Mathematically, the 6- roll works fine. But it means that whenever a character tries a skill roll which an untrained person should have a decent chance of succeeding in, the GM needs to give a huge bonus (like +5). Since Hero System skill rolls are presented as an "absolute" ("13-" instead of "+3"), GM's who don't know the mathematics well may have a tendency to ask for unmodified skill checks. This can result in situations in which ordinary characters are treated as comically incompetent because they routinely miss their skill checks by 5 or more.

The VPP rule explicitly allows you to buy a control cost for more active points than the real cost, so you can have a variable power pool with 30 real points that allows powers of 60 active points. This is something I have always allowed and used, it is mathematically logical (it is as if you bought a 60 point power pool and declared that 30 points of it are fixed in place). This is very useful in practice when you want to create a VPP of attack powers, something quite common. With attack powers, you usually only want one power in the pool at a time, and trying to create an interesting power with advantages and limitations didn't work because the limitations only saved you real points, and you couldn't do anything with these real points. Now you can buy up your active points and have more options for playing around with your VPP.

5th Edition merged Public/Secret ID into a new, more general complication called Social Complication. I like this idea, and the new symmetry of having physical, psychological, and social complications. There were definitely some complications that were hard to represent properly before. Most notably, "subject to orders" was previously represented as "watched by military", which isn't really the same thing.

Martial arts are now fully effective when used with weapons. In previous editions martial maneuvers gave only half the damage bonus when used with weapons, so a fencer would get the same combat penalties for performing an offensive strike as a hand-to-hand fighter, but would only get half the damage bonus, and thus fencers would avoid this maneuver most of the time. This change evens the playing field.

There is no more Package Bonus – you don't get a point break for basing a characer off of a standard template. I didn't particularly object to the package bonus, but this changes seems reasonable, why reward characters for being standardized and penalize creativity. The main justification for the package bonus was that you got a point break for having to buy useless skills, but 6th Edition has fixed this problem by specifying that useless skills no longer cost character points.

Find Weakness is gone. I didn't hate this power, but I never used it either. I found it way too extreme; one roll would determine whether you were devastating or impotent against the enemies. And the game mechanics for how the power worked were rather fiddly and didn't seem to match any power of any character in any genre I was familiar with. It was sort of a funny Hero System-specific gimmick, and I won't miss it.

Many powers and modifiers have been broken down into much more detail, allowing characters to be crafted more precisely. Examples include how you can now use invisible power effects to make something inobvious instead of fully invisible, or how the value of the Linked limitation depends in more detail on exactly how the linking works. These changes are individually small, but overall, I like the breakdowns and added power modifiers, they usually make a lot of sense, and they increase the richness of the character creation system, which is at the heart of the Hero System.

A lot of rules sections are much larger than the corresponding sections in 4th Edition, and in a good way. A lot of things which were unclear before are now explained. Examples of expanded rules sections, include perceivability of powers, constant powers, Adjustment Powers, and Mental Powers, but there are many others. I think a lot of work has gone in to making the rules more clear and comprehensive, and I found the expanded rules sections enlightening on many points.

Key Changes about which I am positive, with reservations:

There is a big new rule, the Multiple Attack rule. Finally, there is a way for a character to make multiple attacks simultaneously – to shoot a gun in each hand, or to trip a foe and headstomp him without letting him get up in between. The maneuver is quite powerful but requires a high OCV and gives you 1/2 DCV. I put the maneuver as a positive because it lets you do something that you just couldn't do before, and sometimes wanted to do. But I have reservations about whether I'd really want to use or allow this maneuver in a game. First, I feel like the characters who would thematically most want to use this would be highly skilled characters fighting minions – but these are exactly the kind of characters who would really hate being reduced to ½ DCV and wiped out by counterattacks from all the remaining minions. Second, it seems like a new way to beat on the poor fools who have been knocked prone or otherwise reduced to ½ DCV. It is bad enough getting auto-hit by normal attacks when you are on the ground, but potentially taking triple damage from a massive multi-attack seems just cruel.

Missile Deflection is gone, replaced by a rule that anyone can block ranged attacks based on special effects. And the rules for Block are nicely expanded. The key to my commentary here is to understand that I'm always thinking of Block as an alternative to Dodge. And the truth is that if your OCV and DCV are equal, Block is only slightly more effective at avoiding a single attack than Dodge, and has many more limitations. It does let you go first next round, but only in certain circumstances. So I feel that the ability to Block isn't worth that much, since you could have just dodged instead. So I am quite happy that Missile Deflection no longer costs a large number of points. And I think the new block rules are swell. My reservations are two. First, since I never really used Block much at all, I'm just not that excited by all the page space spent on it. Second, under the new rules, you can only block range attacks (i.e. Missile Deflect) if you have an appropriate special effect. My opinion is that if you think Block is useful enough to devote all that page space to, why isn't it useful enough to cost at least one point to be able to block ranged attacks? It seems tempting to say "Oh, my character carries around a trash can lid just so he is eligible for this extra combat maneuver".

The Grab rules are much more detailed and better described, and make a lot of sense. A character who is grabbing someone is now at ½ DCV; the -2 DCV penalty only applies if you miss. The grabbed characters have -3 OCV, which seems rough, but the grabber is still ½ DCV against their attacks. If you grab one target, you are ½ OCV against other targets. There are scary optional rules about letting super-strong grabbers really dominate weaker opponents. It is clarified that most martial maneuvers aren't allowed when grabbed. My only reservation is that some aspects of the new rules seem even more favorable to bricks and less favorable to martial artists, and I had already thought that grabs were too good for bricks and not that great for martial artists.

Mega-Scale is a new advantage that lets you create powers with immense area, range, or speed, at a cost that is large but not overwhelmingly huge. I like this idea, it makes it straightforward to buy certain powers that were awkward to buy before, such as the power to fly at the speed of light, or turn an entire city into zombies, or purchase a spaceship with guns that fire millions of kilometers. This acknowledges that in many cases, once you pass a certain amount of scale, increasing the scale of a power is largely for color and shouldn't cost an overwhelming number of points. After all, a sleep spell that covers an entire battlefield is enough for any combat use, increasing it to cover an entire county is probably just something you do when making some special magic ritual for storytelling purposes. However, while I think this is useful, I have reservations about the cost structure. I think the power is great improved over the 5th edition rules, in which it was absurdly cheap, but had annoying little limitations that often forced you to create a multipower for it. Now the cost is much more satisfying. But the cost system is still really weird. The first strangeness is that there were already ways to logarithmically increase the scale of powers, and megascale isn't integrated into the existing system. This is most obvious with area effect; you can get an area effect of 4m radius, or pay more for 8m or 16m; but once your power is 64m radius, you can just decide to make is 4000m radius for the same cost. This probably won't hurt the game balance if the GM is careful not to allow abusive megascale constructions, but it sure is weird. What is really odd is how megascale works with movement powers. Say you have 60m of teleport. It you buy megascale on top of it, you pay a staggering number of points to be able to teleport 60km. Or you can buy a small teleport with megascale in a multipower and be able to teleport anywhere on the planet for a handful of points. Megascale is a clear example of just how arbitrary the Hero System point costs really are; mega-scale is either very expensive or dirt cheap. And in particular, even if the GM and players are trying hard not to abuse the rules, it still isn't obvious which way is the "right" or "fair" cost. The planetary teleport multipower seems unfairly cheap, but if you use the megascale rules totally "straight up", then characters with large amounts of combat teleport pay far more points in order to have the same amount of noncombat teleport, and this seems pretty unfair the opposite way.

Key Changes I am neutral or conflicted about:

The ability to use EGO to defend against PRE attacks is now an optional rule. I don't have much opinion on this either way. In any case, if you really wanted your strong-willed but quiet character to resist PRE attacks, you could buy PRE with the limitation "only for defense".

Haymaker is substantially changed. First, it now gives a fixed damage boost of +4d6. I think this is good as it matches the way martial maneuvers work and reduces that massive benefit of haymakers to super-strong bricks, although my reservation is that it is weird and awkward that characters of ordinary human strength gets such an overwhelming benefit from the maneuver. The second change is a more of a clarification. A haymaker takes extra time between launching it and landing it, and if the foe moved out of range it would miss – but what if they just moved to a different place in your range? Now it is specified that if the foe moves at all, the haymaker misses, even if you have stretching or can otherwise still reach the target. I like this clarification. Third, and most importantly, any power can now be Haymakered, even if it is ranged! I like this because in the past, Bricks were much better at performing finishing blows or damaging inanimate objects than Energy Projectors, and now this evens the playing field. My big reservation is that I have never liked the Haymaker rule and never use it in my games, I don't like how it is far more effective than a regular attack unless the opponent has the correct meta-game knowledge of how to defend against it, in which case it is totally neutralized. So I'm not really thrilled that far more characters can now use it!

Flashes were changed in 5th edition to give you twice as many dice for the points, but the effect lasts for segments rather than phases. I can't decide if this change is good or bad. It means that 5 points of flash defense doesn't neutralize almost all flashes completely, and makes it more straightforward how long flash lowers your DCV and Perceptions, and makes flash slightly less devastating, and doesn't give as much penalty to low SPD characters. But what you really care about with Flash is how many phases you are affected for, and now that varies based upon arbitrary meta-game considerations: the segment your foe goes on compared to you. And the idea of a delaying your action when you are flashed to a later segment in which you are unflashed seems odd and slows the game down.

Breakfall lets you stand up as a zero phase action. Hmm, I foresee a lot of characters with breakfall skill. This rule isn't bad, it has the advantage of creating a way to ignore the prone effect, makes people with breakfall skill feel more distinctive, and gives breakfall a benefit even when you are knocked into obstacles. But in practical terms it makes me uneasy in two ways. First, I find the ability to delay people by knocking them prone feels appropriate, but don’t much care for the ability to reduce them to ½ DCV just long enough for your friends with reserved actions to annihilate them. The new breakfall rule takes away the first part without removing the second, I'd rather have it remove both or neither. Second, this is one of those rolls you have to make a lot but won't likely fail very often, and my experience with activation rolls is that such rolls can be somewhat of a nuisance.

The simulated sense group rule. When you buy an enhanced sense, you can say what sense group it is part of (such as sight or hearing) and it gains some of the benefits of the natural sense in that group, for free. The biggest effect of this rule is that enhanced senses which allow you to ignore sight-group flash, darkness, and invisibility cost more than those that don't, since senses based on sight get Targeting for free. This is good, because the ability to ignore sensory attacks is often the primary combat effect of an enhanced sense. On the other hand, the rest of the rule just seems awkward. You have to pay a bunch of points to make your mystic treasure sense ranged, but the ability to "smell" treasure is ranged for free, this just seems arbitrary to me. It seems like this whole rule would be more naturally replaced by limitations or advantages when you buy senses that are more more or less affected by sensory powers. Another point I should make is that it seems like it would be very common to imagine some sort of special vision that is affected by sight-based flashes but not affected by sight-based darkness or invisibility. The simulated senses rule doesn't cover this, it assumes flash and darkness/invisibility work the same way.

Dive for Cover makes you prone, and you suffer extra knockback if you try to dive for cover and fail. This makes sense if you think of the maneuver as literally diving to the ground to escape a grenade blast or an exploding car, and that sort of thing certainly happens in the movies. On the other hand, I'm somewhat skeptical of the literal interpretation. When you are diving from a grenade, you want to land prone because being prone inherently protects you. It seems a little odd that under the Dive for Cover rules, you run 8 meters, then decide to fall prone even though it doesn't protect you in any way under the Hero System rules. I liked the idea that Dive for Cover could be used to simulate the fact that it is difficult to hit fast-moving superheroes with area effect attacks. But the maneuver is rather difficult to use in superhero combat (they can just throw another area attack next phase), and the changes just make it even less effective. But perhaps I'm asking too much of the maneuver, and should just consider it to be designed to simulate characters trying to avoid single massive explosions by running away, leaping, and landing on the ground.

Key Changes I feel are detrimental:

The cost structure of combat skill levels has changed in a negative way. In 4th Edition is was noticeable that combat skill levels in highly limited areas were too cheap and versatile skill levels were too expensive. In 6th Edition, the cost of versatile skill levels was made even more expensive and the cost of limited levels stayed the same. Now a skill level in all combat costs 10 points! This means that the ability to gain +1 in OCV or DCV costs as much as buying both +1 OCV and +1 DCV! The combat level does allow you the option of increasing damage, but this is a small benefit compared to doubling the total combat bonus. Yet a level that applies to your 3 favorite maneuvers you use almost all the time is still a measly 3 points. Basically, 6th Edition increased the cost of levels in all combat or all h-to-h combat so that "1 level in martial arts" could now cost more than a level in 3 specific martial maneuvers and less than a level in all hand-to-hand combat. Inserting this new level is logical, but the specific way the costs were changed is not.

Also, the cost of mental combat levels was changed to work differently from physical combat levels, to match the fact that +1 OCMV is cheaper than +1 OCV. So gaining +1 in one mental attack is now half as expensive as +1 in one physical attack. This makes no sense. It isn't clear whether OMCV really should be cheaper than OCV, but if it should, it would be because it covers fewer powers. Once you are restricting your level to only a single power, +1 to hit is +1 to hit, it should cost the same to get +1 with a single mental power as it costs to get +1 with a single physical power, as they are both equally useful. Certainly it isn't like mental powers are weaker than physical powers – quite the opposite, at least for mental blasts.

The killing attack STUN multipliers for hit locations were NOT changed, even though the general STUN multipliers for killing attacks were changed. This means that killing attacks do far more stun damage if you are using the hit location rules. I find this very puzzling, especially since a few pages later in the rules is a discussion of how it is a problem in heroic campaigns that killing attacks tend to knock foes out instead of killing them. It is as if the hit location rules (indeed, almost all of the optional combat rules) were simply copied verbatim from the previous editions without being re-edited.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Analyzing Hero System 6th Edition – Major Changes

I've been hard at work reading and analyzing the rules for 6th Edition Hero System. I've played Champions for a long time, and it has traditionally been what I consider to be my favorite roleplaying game, though I haven't played it a whole lot recently. I remember how pleased I was with the 4th Edition, and I played that for a long time. I wasn't too pleased with the 5th Edition; while it was not without its good points, it seemed "fiddly", and had twice as many pages without much improvement to the game. I played it a bit, but didn't really see it as supplanting the 4th Edition rules. Now the 6th Edition has come out, and I have to say I'm much more pleased. This seems like it really is an improvement to the game, something that could make me want to put away the old Big Blue Book of 4th Edition.


It should be understood that while there are substantial changes, the game was not "recreated" in the sense of 4th edition D&D, this is an evolutionary modification and most of the rules are still the same as 4th edition Hero System. So I think I shall analyze it in terms of how the system has changed. Since I was not that impressed with 5th Edition, never wrote an analysis of the 5th Edition changes and have many friends who never played 5th Edition, I shall compare the changes to 4th Edition Hero System, with maybe a few mentions of 5th Edition here and there.


For this article, I will be looking at the really broad changes to the game, those changes you would be likely to notice regardless of what powers or maneuvers your character uses.


First, since I will be using these terms later, I'll mention the major nomenclature changes.

  • Ego Combat Value is now called Mental Combat Value (MCV), and in general the word "Mental" replaces "Ego" when referring to mental combat, rather than your Ego characteristic. I think this change is great. I always felt that the use of the word "Ego" instead of "Mental" was a bit of Hero System-specific weirdness.
  • Disadvantages are now called Complications. I never had a problem with the old term, but agree that the new term is just as good or better.


Major changes I feel improve the game:

  • The pricing system for characteristics was changed to remove the concept of secondary characteristics from the game. This is a big change, and is just a good thing. A well-known strangeness of previous versions was that purchasing STR and CON actually gave you more points worth of figured characteristics that you paid for the primary characteristic. This meant that, in some sense, these characteristics had a negative cost – increasing them could make the character cheaper! To deal with this, it was necessary to put limits on how many figured characteristics you could buy down, artificially limiting your character design. There were other minor drawbacks as well related to the fact that the "active points" of these characteristics were not equal to their "real cost". The one minor advantage of the old system was that it gave you a nice simple way to compute default values for your REC, END, and STUN, so that you didn't have to think about them. But in my opinion, the new system is far superior.
  • OCV and DCV are now characteristics, rather than being calculated from DEX. I highly approve of this, and in fact, had been moving strongly in this direction in my Champions house rules. When designing how a character will work in combat, it was cumbersome that base OCV, base DCV, and base Dex roll were all inextricably linked together. Sometimes I would want to make a character who was very skilled in combat, but not necessarily a great acrobat. You could do this with levels in OCV and DCV, which was OK, but levels and base CV are not quite the same thing. Other times, I would want to make a character who had been gifted with superhuman reflexes but didn't really know how to fight. There was no elegant way to do this (you would have to simulate it with a complication), but now it is easy. Also, it is quite normal to want a character's combat "style" to be more defensive or more offensive, and as mentioned above, having this be represented by setting your base OCV or DCV directly is more natural than buying levels in OCV or DCV. There is one tiny downside to this – Adjustment powers that affect your "agility" are more cumbersome to purchase, as adjusting DEX no longer adjusts OCV and DCV. But this is a very minor drawback.
  • The separation of OCV and DCV from DEX also has another potential benefit. An old Champions tradition is that superhero characters have much higher dexterity than their conceptions would indicate. If you wanted to be a slow, clumsy brick, you would have DEX 18, and if you were just average, DEX 20. Yet these would be considered quite high values for normal people. And superhero characters had normal, conception-appropriate values for other characteristics like INT and STR, so the high DEX was an oddity. The high DEX was actually a good thing for balance purposes. Some superheroes really do have good reason to have superhuman DEX. But if some characters had DEX 30 and others DEX 10, this meant some characters would have CV 10, others CV 3. This is way too much difference in a combat system in which even a few points of CV have a huge effect. Also, the high DEX meant that superheroes had a much higher CV than normal people. This isn't essential, but was part of the game balance and had some nice effects, letting characters do some fancy things and really feel impressive against ordinary mooks. The problem with the boosted DEX was that it also meant that superheroes had very high DEX rolls regardless of real conception. It was just weird that a superhero of average intelligence and average dexterity would have 11- in his intelligence-based skills and 13- in his dex-based skills, for no really good reason. With this new change, it is finally practically to really fix this strangeness; you can give superheroes abnormally high DCV and OCV but give them DEX on the same scale as INT. They don't do this with their sample superheroes, but I plan to with my campaign.
  • OMCV and DMCV (the mental combat values) are also characteristics. Not only does this have the benefits listed above for OCV and DCV, it also has point benefits. DCV and ECV used to have the same cost when you factored out the points of SPD given to you by the DEX. Now MDCV costs less than DCV, which is appropriate as it is less often useful. And in the past, EGO was expensive because it was a key statistic for mentalists, so characters without mental powers were really charged a lot for it even though all they wanted was to be strong-willed to fit their conception. Now characters who don't have mental powers don't even have to pay for OMCV, only characters who actually gain benefits from OMCV have to pay for it. There is, however, a drawback to the new system; mentalists can refuse to buy OCV and actually end up cheaper than non-mentalists, which is peculiar because mentalists are usually more effective than OCV-based characters, not less. And it sort of puts a high price tag on characters whose multipowers include both mental attacks and normal attacks, and thus need both OCV and OMCV. But overall, I like the new system.
  • The Comeliness characteristic has been replaced with the Striking Appearance advantage. This is interesting because I'd been thinking for a long time that if I wanted to rewrite Hero System, I would do exactly this. Nobody really cared about Comeliness too much, so it shouldn't be a characteristic. And the numbers had little game meaning anyway. It makes a lot more sense to either say "my character has average appearance" and forget about it, or to say "my character has an extraordinary appearance" and actually describe what game benefit you want to get from that.
  • The way that the base points for characters is described has been changed. In previous editions, a standard "250 point" Champions character was described as having 100 base points plus up to 150 points of disadvantages. Now such a character would be described as a 250 point character with 150 points of matching Complications. This works the same way, but better matches the fact that Champions players have always described such a character as 250 points rather than 100 points. Also, all powers and abilities which refer to the point cost of a character (such as Followers or Multiform) refer to this total cost, 250 points, rather than making a hard-to-remember distinction between base cost and total cost.
  • A longstanding complaint of mine has been that Champions demands that you take enormous numbers of Disadvantages, more than most character conceptions would naturally want to take, and more than most players or GM's would really want to use in play. 6th Edition has met this complaint straight on the nose! They directly acknowledge in the rules advice the problems of having to take too many Complications, and the recommended Complication points for a superhero has been halved, from 150 to 75.
  • There is now a rule that "background" powers and skills which don't really have any game effect, don't cost any points. I love this rule (just as I loved it where I first saw it, in 4th edition D&D). I have often noted that background skills, like being a master violinist, are way overpriced because they very rarely come up in play, and thought they should be far cheaper. Making them free certainly simplifies the situation! I also like how they mention that even skills with clearly listed values, like Bugging, can cost few or no points if the GM doesn't expect them to come up in the game. This is exactly what happens in real games. You are making some superhero whose background is that he was a secret agent, and you figure he ought to have bugging. But if you buy the Bugging skill, it is a waste of points, because it never comes up in your superhero adventures. But if you don't buy it, then there just might be one point every 5 years that you actually need Bugging – perhaps in some minor way – and you won't have it, even though it would be so cool to finally use your spy skills. The new suggestions are entirely on point to fix this problem.
  • The frequency concept for Complications such as Hunted has been greatly improved. In previous versions, you were supposed to make a random roll every adventure to see if the disadvantage showed up. I never played with anyone who actually followed that rule. First, the randomness would screw up your ability to create properly planned, believable adventures. Second, the hunters would show up far too frequently; the "medium" freqency would have them show up in more than half of the adventures! 6th Edition has done a great job addressing this. The random rolls are gone, and the recommended frequencies have been reduced. And the repetitive attacks by hunters are reduced even further by helpful advice that even when they do "show up", it doesn't have to mean they attack or directly interfere with the character, or even that they show up – it may just mean that the character's behavior is influenced by his knowledge of being hunted.
  • Another longstanding complaint of mine about Champions has been the ridiculous randomness of the stun damage caused by killing attacks. It meant they were just as good as normal attacks of the same point cost at causing stun damage – and better if the target's defenses were high. And they were certainly much more likely to stun the opponent. A rifle bullet could be more effective against a bulletproof superhero than an energy blast, directly contrary to the comics. This has been fixed in 6th edition by making the stun multiplier for killing attacks 1d3 instead of 1d6-1. They are still very random, but they are now clearly inferior to normal attacks at causing stun damage, with their advantage being that they cause more body damage. I still find the killing attack rules awkward in various respects, but I think this is an improvement.
  • Also, there is no longer a rule that you have to have at least one point of resistant defense in order to use your non-resistant defense against the stun damage of a killing attack. Now you can always use it. It was silly that there was a "magic cutoff" between having one point of resistant defense and having none – characters who took zero resistant defense were hosing themselves and not getting any points back in return. Now, it must be said that the old rule seemed like a logical way to prevent totally unarmored characters from shrugging off the stun damage from small killing attacks. But the truth is that the rule that you always take at least one STUN for every point of BODY damage already prevents this – and with the new killing attack rules, you don't necessarily expect killing attacks to cause a whole lot of STUN damage anyway.
  • Heroic Action Points. Champions is a very old RPG, and it did not have any form of "hero points" to give the players some sort of narrative control over the luck of the dice, save their characters from disasters, and let them rise to heroic occasions outside of the rather limited-purpose pushing rules. This became a noticeable omission when newer games had hero points, and Hero System didn't, despite the fact that the core of the Hero System has always been the sort of dramatic, cinematic adventures in which hero points are most appropriate. Well, now the Hero System has hero points! They are called Heroic Action Points, and they let you do a variety of things, most notably to retroactively modify your dice rolls. The rule isn't too sophisticated, but I'm not inclined to critique it. It seems like a perfectly workable rule, and it has been added to a game system that never had it before!
  • 4th Edition suggested restricting characters using active point limits on their attacks, and 5th Edition really took this to heart (their sample superteam, the Champions, seemed to have a 12d6 attack for every single character!). I was pleased to see that 6th Edition makes an about face, and has a very realistic discussion of the disadvantages of this approach, how it encourages sameness and discourages creative powers, how not all advantages that increase active points really count as boosting the combat effectiveness, how powers may be more or less powerful than their points indicate, and how the GM may be better off evaluating the real effectiveness of powers.
  • The Hero System has a history of good GM suggestions, and 6th edition definitely keeps up the fine work. Aside from the usual fine material about making campaigns and running games, I was impressed to find sections that explain how certain game mechanics really work and what they do to the game – just the sort of things I write about in my blog. There seems to be real understanding of the implications of various game mechanics, and even explanations of some of the weaknesses of the system and how you might work around them.


Major Changes about which I am positive, with reservations:

  • The characteristic costs were changed around. Some of the old primary characteristics had to be changed due to the removal of the figured characteristic concept, but it is interesting how they changed. STR was not made cheaper at all, despite the fact that it used to give you enormous numbers of figured characteristics. DEX had its cost adjusted appropriately to 2 for the removal of the SPD benefit, but got no discount at all for losing its most important function, providing CV. CON was reduced appropriately reduced to cost 1 after losing its figured characteristics. BODY was adjusted to 1 for losing its Stun benefit. EGO now costs the same amount if you want only the Ego roll and DMCV benefit, but costs more if you also want OMCV. Finally, the cost of REC, END, and Stun was just flat out chopped in half. Why I think this is positive: While it may be odd that no-range STR is as expensive as ranged Blast, Bricks get all sorts of combat maneuvers and benefits that energy projectors don't have, so this seems plausible. DEX is a skill stat just like INT, and also gives you some extra combat benefits, so it is reasonable that it costs more than INT. Mentalists are really, really effective, so charging them more for their EGO is not a bad idea. People rarely bought up REC, END, and Stun very much, and they were a bit pricey compared to Def. That isn't the case anymore! My reservations: Ego rolls are fairly rare, and I always felt EGO was too expensive for non-mentalists, so I think EGO should be cheaper. STR is now more fairly priced for bricks and fantasy warriors, but is now overpriced for characters who don't use it for their combat attacks. Stun was a bit pricey compared to super-efficient point expenditures like increasing your PD, Dex, or STR, but it was actually quite reasonably priced compared to most expenditures, like buying skills or life support, so I'm not all that excited by making it just as dirt cheap as the other optimum ways of increasing your raw combat power.
  • The minimum cost rules are gone, or rather are relegated to a note that the GM can optionally impose whatever minimum costs he thinks are appropriate. This is good because there are many perfectly valid power constructions which require less than the minimum points from a power, and the minimum points rule was just getting in the way. My only reservation is that there are a few cases in which having a power at all gives you some fixed benefit, and now that benefit can be had for really cheap. For instance, 1" of flight lets you walk on air, and 1" of teleport lets you escape from grabs automatically. But the minimum cost rule wasn't the mathematically correct solution to this problem anyway, so this really isn't much of a reservation.
  • The new rules have a number of sidebars about "Toolkitting". These are suggestions for how you might want to change the game to create house rules to address certain problems that might crop up with the regular rules. I think it is great that the game openly admits that its rules may have imperfections or need to be changed based on the situation, and encourages the use of house rules. I'm certainly a big fan of house rules! And I like the suggestions for what to do, many of them are fairly sensible. My only "reservation" is to note that many of the suggestions are pretty vague, and suggesting that you might want to solve a problem is not the same as actually having rules to fix the problem.


Major Changes I am neutral about:

  • The entire system for measuring distance has been changed from "game inches" to meters. Actually, I quite like getting rid of "game inches", that was confusing. But the change could have been to use the term "hexes", and instead they switched totally to "meters". I view this as a stylistic change, neither good and bad. Measuring in hexes is better for tactical combat, measuring in meters is better when you are playing without a map. It is more pleasing to read everything being described in meters, but the tactical rules are still the same underneath and are easier to play with hexes. As a side note, I find it interesting that D&D 4th edition made the exact opposite change – from feet to squares.


There are no major, sweeping changes which I dislike. They seem to have done a pretty good job with 6th Edition!

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Balancing The Game To Encourage Genre Appropriate Actions

One of my primary goals when designing game mechanics is to make the game encourage actions which are genre-appropriate, fun, or fit well with the theme of the game. Encouragement can mean different things, but it most often means making that action one of the best possible actions from the competitive point of view (winning the game or defeating the adventure).

Let's create an example of what I'm trying to prevent. Imagine you have a fencer in a swashbuckling adventure game. The character concept, and the genre, imply that he should frequently use his weapon to disarm his opponents, rather than simply stabbing them.

In most traditional roleplaying games, the disarm maneuver involves the attacker making some sort of (often fairly difficult) roll to successfully force the defender to drop his weapon. So the game has fulfilled the mechanical requirement of permitting the character to disarm the foe.

The problem is that the disarmed opponent can then spend his action to pick the weapon back up. So all the fencer has done is spend an entire action to force the opponent to spend an action. And that is if he succeeds in the disarm; otherwise, he has spent an action for no effect. So overall, disarm costs an action for the attacker in order to cost the defender less than an action. Not very useful.

Now, one might point out that there are situations where this disarm maneuver is indeed useful. In particular, if there are two PC's fighting one opponent, one PC can disarm the opponent, and the other can pick up the weapon, leaving the defender unarmed and helpless. Or if you are fighting near a cliff or in a bog, you may be able to disarm an opponent and have the weapon be lost for good. Also, you can use disarm just to waste time, in case the situation doesn't require you to win, or if you are one-on-one with a more powerful opponent and want to delay matters until your allies arrive.

Unfortunately, none of this really helps the situation at hand, which is capturing the spirit of a swashbuckler movie where the fencer frequently disarms opponents in situations where none of these are true. Indeed, the fencer is often outnumbered and pressed for time, yet still disarms the opponents. But when playing a game with standard disarm rules, one would very quickly realize that this is totally ineffective and basically a waste of time, and the player would want to start stabbing opponents to win the battle.

One response to this would be to say that the swashbuckler has a psychological limitation that makes him enjoy disarming opponents even though it isn't really effective, just because he enjoys doing so. This limitation could give him the points to be such a good fencer that he can get away with some nonsense and still win the fights. But I don't really feel like this is true to the source material or the character. If this were true, you'd expect the other characters in the movie to say, "Wow, that guy's a good fencer. Too bad he's a grandstanding moron!" But they don't do so, and the movie doesn't convey that impression. Indeed, the character concept for the swashbuckler may well be that of a reluctant hero forced to fight for an important cause, not a that of an egotist enraptured with his own fencing skill. Also, if the psychological limitation theory were true, you'd expect the swashbuckler to drop the disarming when he has to save the life of his true love, but that doesn't really seem to happen in the source material.

A slightly different response would be to say that because disarming is appropriate to the source material, it is the player's responsibility to throw in some disarm attempts as "good roleplaying". The idea of expecting players to help make the game fun is a good one. I don't generally play roleplaying games in a highly competitive style, and in the roleplaying games I play in, it is understood that the players don't just go all-out to optimize every game mechanic to win the game, but try to do fun things and advance the story, or at least make the battles entertaining. There is no way to balance everything perfectly or guarantee that the most entertaining move is the most effective. You expect the players to mix things up and put some variety in the game even if a careful analysis may reveal that a more boring strategy is somewhat more effective. But I generally think this sort of thing works best when the game balance between the different actions being considered is pretty close. A lot of the time, you may suspect a certain action isn't optimal, but there are pros and cons both ways, so it isn't really clear. So you really feel free to do whatever you think is cool.

For instance, in Torg you had the ability to take "approved actions" each round, like taunting or tricking the opponent, instead of just attacking them. Success would give you a minor advantage over the foe and an extra card. We loved approved actions, they were cool, and we did them over and over. We always strongly suspected that just attacking the foe would be more effective; ending the battle early is generally a good thing. But the benefit of cards was hard to quantify; they could set you up for a big attack later on, and could potentially be saved for use later in the adventure. And approved action were fun, and Torg characters were so full of possibilities (hero points) that you weren't that scared of combat anyway. So it all seemed to work OK. Actually, though, I should admit that in this case I did make some rules changes to make the approved actions a bit better and encourage them more.

However, when one action is just flat out way inferior to another, even in cases where it ought to be useful, that is just going way beyond the scope of what should be expected from the players. In the case of the disarm example, using disarm in most situations isn't an interesting choice with pros and cons; it is just a way to make your character less effective. The more you use it, the less effective you are. It is basically as if the GM is saying, "I'd like you to vary your actions to make the combat more interesting. Whenever you do so, I will punish you by making you less effective. The more interesting you are, the more I will punish you." It is perverse and unfortunate, and even though players can and often do make games more entertaining this way, it would be much better if the rules were changed so that they were not made ineffective by doing so.

On a related note, the players can bypass various forms of rules abuse by following conventions. For instance, in Champions, when an enemy strongman jumped up to you and started trying to smash your face in, it was most effective within the rules to ignore that person and attack a weaker enemy. Nothing in the rules required you to pay any attention to enemies attacking you; even if you were virtually surrounded on all sides with angry swordsmen, you were free to run off to a different part of the battlefield as if they were all paralyzed and attack the vulnerable boss behind them. Since this was totally inappropriate to the genre (and reality too), we made a convention that you were expected to defend yourself when attacked and had to do something if you wanted to fight your way past the attacker. This was a good convention; conventions can be useful to fix bad rules or substitute for rules that don't exist. But it is even better to fix or create the rule, rather than having a convention. Then you know exactly when the rule applies and what the penalty is for breaking it. In any case, the idea of making a convention doesn't work well for disarm example because it isn't clear how you would apply the convention. Saying that you had to disarm every other attack would just be way too unnatural.

Another way to deal with the issue here is for the GM to compensate by rewarding genre-appropriate maneuvers. I highly approve of having the GM reward genre-appropriate maneuvers with cool custom bonuses. But this is best for things done infrequently. If the genre rarely involved disarming opponents, and you suddenly had a good reason to do so as a surprise maneuver to liven things up, it would be very appropriate for the GM to make up some sort of bonus on the spot. But if you disarm constantly as part of the genre, custom bonuses aren't very practical. If you give the same bonus every time, you've created a rule, and the rule might as well be written down. If not, you start to play a game where the GM is just making up the rules arbitrarily. You can do this, of course - you can roleplay without any rules at all if you want to. But the assumption here is that we are playing a game with rules, and the premise behind playing a game with rules is that, most of the time, it is better to have a rule than rely on pure GM arbitrariness.

So for all of these reasons, I would want to devise an improvement to the disarm rule. One could argue against this by pointing out that boosting the disarm power as written shouldn't be done because it would be too strong and would break the game in the situations where disarm is already a useful ability. This is true, but simply means that attempting to fix the problem requires rethinking the rule rather than simply boosting it. Part of the skill in modifying game rules is making sure that you don't create more problems than you fix. Just because my game analysis indicates that a game has some sort of problem or imperfection doesn't mean I will make a rule to fix it. I only make a rules change if I think the new rule will be better overall than the previous rule.

The truth is that every game is going to have problems simply because of the choices made in meeting various conflicting design goals. And sometimes those elements that make the game fun also seem to have disadvantages too. For instance, one of my favorite board games is History of the World. But it has the disadvantage that more than 6 hours to play. It can be hard to get people to play for this reason. But the length of the game is related to the fact that it plays out the "History of the World", and that is part of what I like about it. I haven't really thought of any clever way to speed up with game without detracting from the epic quality I like about it. So I haven't tried to make a rule to speed up the game, I just consider the length part of the pros and cons of a game I really like overall. I feel that putting in a simple-minded rule to speed up the game - like playing for only 3 turns - would make the game worse rather than better.

But if I did think of a way to make the game just as fun but twice as fast, I wouldn't hestitate to try it out. Just because a rule is hard to improve upon doesn't mean you shouldn't try. Sometimes I try a lot of experiments, and a lot of those experiments fail. Sometimes I try experimental rules that I know won't work perfectly, just to get information. But in the end, the goal is to craft a new rule that is better overall than the previous rule.

By the way, I've never really come up with what I would call a perfect solution to the disarming problem, only various ideas. One example of an idea would be to use the 4th edition D&D power design philosophy and have disarming be a special attack that causes damage, with the special effect that the damage is totally abstract and the attack looks totally non-violent. Attacks which fail to kill have the bonus effect of temporarily disarming the enemy; attacks which kill the enemy either look like kills on-screen, or the enemy looks like he is still conscious but is counted as "defeated" and no longer has any game effect on the battle.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Identity of the character roles in 4th edition D&D

In 4th edition D&D, there are 4 official character roles: Defender, Striker, Leader, Controller. Each role is supposed to have a specific purpose within the party. I've observed that some of the roles have a clear, unified identity, while other roles seem to be a combination of multiple sub-roles which could potentially be separated.

The purpose of a striker is to deal maximum damage to a single opponent, and the powers given to strikers allow them to deal extra damage to a single opponent. This is the simplest and most pure of the roles. There is one clear purpose to the role, and one type of power which directly serves that purpose.

Actually, the description in the Player’s Handbook mentions that strikers also have powers to help them single out a specific target they want to attack. But in practice this doesn’t really seem to be a distinction, different strikers have a wide variety of powers that help them or inhibit them from attacking a specific target, or no such powers at all.

The purpose of a defender is to protect the party by absorbing the enemy’s attacks. Defenders have two powers to achieve this – the ability to force enemies to attack the defender instead of someone else, and high defenses to absorb that damage. This is slightly more complicated than the striker, since these two powers could mechanically be separated – you could have the ability to draw attacks without having high defenses. But it doesn’t seem like a good idea! If you have the ability to draw attacks, having high defenses is practically required, so really defenders have a single clearly identifiable focus.

Leaders have one purpose – to help out the rest of the party – and two sub-roles – healing and support (support referring to improving teamwork and making other party members more effective). In terms of theme, these naturally fit together as ways of helping out the rest of the party. But mechanically, there is no particular reason these two sub-roles need to be combined. It would work perfectly fine to have a character with healing and no support abilities, or vice-versa. The reason to fit them together is that both fulfill the leader’s purpose, so if you want to play your character as being the party’s support character, you would want both abilities.

Controllers are the real mystery. Controllers have strong area effect attacks, and the ability to place enemies under various conditions. What these two types of powers have to do with each other beats me. They don’t seem related in either game mechanics or theme. The controller role doesn’t seem very descriptive. When I see references to a class having “controller abilities”, I never know which type of power that refers to. The theme of the controller seems to be “the offense-oriented class that isn’t a striker”.

Maybe the purpose of grouping these powers under the controller role is based more on having a fair division of labor. 25% of the characters focus on concentrated damage, 25% on absorbing damage, and 25% on healing and support, and 25% on other forms of offense. By putting one of each role in the party, you know you have everything covered. If there were separate roles for area effect offense and true control, there would be five roles, and if players chose them evenly, then 40% of the party would be special offense. If 25% special offense is the right amount, then having 5 roles would lead to too much special offense and not enough of the other roles. So perhaps grouping multiple abilities under controller leads to a good distribution of classes.

This reminds me somewhat of Champions, where some of the classic roles were Brick, Martial Artist, Energy Projector, Mentalist, and Other. Other wasn’t very descriptive – it just referred to characters who had some sort of strange powers. You might have the power to control luck, or to turn into an energy-draining ghost, or to transform enemies into animals. It didn’t really say much about what exactly you were or what you did. But when it came to party composition, it was sort of fitting that a “classic” party would have a good selection of traditional superhero archetypes, plus room for one character who does something totally different, whatever it may be.

Next related post: Comparing Champions roles with D&D roles

Saturday, July 25, 2009

Full Defense actions

This week I am discussing some of the issues behind the “full defense” actions in games. A classic full defense action is a type of combat maneuver in many games in which you spend an entire round (depending on how the game manages time) doing nothing but defend yourself, and in return the attacker suffers a penalty to hit you. In some games you have to declare the full defense maneuver without knowing whether you are attacked, while in other games you can declare full defense in response to being attacked. For purposes of discussion both have similar properties, although obviously the latter is a much more favorable rule.

The important game effect of a true full defense action is that it is not a maneuver performed for the purpose of winning the combat. In a straight one-on-one combat where your goal is to defeat the opponent without being defeated yourself, in the absense of extenuating circumstances, performing a full defense action is always a losing maneuver – it increases your chance of being defeated. Many games are deceptive in this regard, implying that a full defense action is an appropriate reaction to being attacked in a heated combat. When the full defense maneuver is named something like "Parry”, and you have the option to take full defense on some actions and attack on other actions, this may at first glance seem like a reasonable idea. But in fact, this is not so. Every round in which you perform a full defense action, you cannot hurt the opponent, but they have a chance of hurting you. In abstract terms, essentially what you are doing is taking a small amount of damage in return for slowing down the combat. But in a straight out one-on-one combat for victory, slowing down the combat (i.e. making it take longer to finish) has no benefit whatsoever, since the combat keeps going until one person wins or the other. So the full defense has no tactical value. It is only useful if there is some way in which the tactical situation is significantly different from this simplified straight up one-on-one combat.

As I mentioned, some games are deceptive and may even give combat example suggesting that it would be appropriate to occasionally respond to an attack with a full defense action, one with a deceptive name such as Parry or Block or Dodge. The trouble is that the kind of parry or block which one might perform as part of a duel is simply not at all modeled by the full defense action. In many games, that sort of defensive action is something the character is assumed to perform automatically as part of a normal attack action. So the good roleplayer should be describing how he blocked or dodged attacks which miss him, rather than actually using the full defense action. A classic full defense should be not be expected in this situation; a player shouldn’t be penalized with a lower chance of winning the battle just because he is creative in describing his actions. I really like how 4th edition D&D calls the maneuver “total defense”, making it perfectly clear that a full defense is an extreme action that takes you temporarily out of the fight.

However, full defense is only truly useless in the abstraction of the straight one-on-one combat, and only if the game does not define other interacting rules to make it more effective. So I will go over some of situations in which full defense can be effective – the situations that define what the purpose of a full defense rule actually is.

For the purposes of this discussion, I will define full defense as a “winning combat maneuver” in situations where it could possibly increase your chance of winning a straight up one-on-one fight, and a "losing combat maneuver" in situations in which it can do nothing but lose such a fight.

First, I shall describe some of the ways in which games can adjust the rules to transform a full defense action into a winning combat manevuer.

1. In some games, characters do not always have the same number of actions; some characters may earn actions at a faster rate than others. If a character is allowed to use full defense against every enemy attack action, and the character still has actions left over, he can use his extra actions to attack. This means that it is mathematically possible that this could be a winning strategy – that the reduction of the enemy’s chance of hitting could actually be more significant than the reduction to the faster character’s number of actions, such that the faster character gains a fighting edge by using full defense. In order for this to work, the defense bonus for the full defense action needs to be fairly large, unless for some reason the characters have far more actions than the opponents.
An example of this is Champions. In that game if you have a 6 speed and 11 dcv, and the opponent has 4 speed and 9 ocv, then if you dodge every time you are attacked, you lose 2/3 of your actions, but the opponent's chance of hitting is reduced by more than 3/4. Therefore, you come out ahead by dodging.
Unfortunately, Champions also shows the weakness of this approach. If dodging is good, then a lot of dodging is better. But if you dodge every enemy attack, then even your own offense is reduced by 2/3, and the fight would take 3 times as long to play out. Ignoring the question of who wins or loses, this just isn't fun because the fight becomes interminably long. And in fact, Champions characters actually heal at a fairly rapid rate during combat, so in fact the fight could go on practically forever. It is so impractical I’ve never seen anyone even consider trying this. It does mean that the fast character could choose to occasionally dodge just for fun without being penalized, which is amusing. But mechanically, the trade-off between effectiveness and tedium is not a very desirable one.

2. Some games give you a bonus in later rounds of combat when you perform the full defense action. In Torg, performing a full defense action successfully can sometimes let you draw an extra card. In the Lost Worlds combat booklet game (this is not an RPG, but still works as an example), if you perform a full defense action against the right kinds of attacks, the enemy may be pulled out of position and vulnerable to your counter attack. I like this method of turning full defense into a winning combat maneuver, it seems like a flexible and fun approach. It does not restrict whether the full defense bonus needs to be small or large, since you can simply adjust the additional bonus you are giving to be smaller or larger.
The tricky point here is that if full defense is a good way to set your next round of combat, you can easily end up in a situation where every character simply alternates between full defense and attack every other round of combat. This isn't a disaster, but it is strange and awkward. Both of the games I listed above have ways to prevent this problem. In Torg, you can only get a bonus card for dodging if defense is an approved action that round, and it is random which actions are approved each round. Lost Worlds is a game based on the “outguess” principle of rock-paper-scissors, so any predictable strategy like this will automatically lose.

3. It is possible to design the game so that what might, at first glance, appear to be a classic full defense action, is actually something different once you consider the interaction with the other rules. For instance, in Burning Wheel, at first glance some of the individual combat maneuvers such as Block appear to be full defense actions which would act strictly as losing combat maneuvers. But this assumes you can only perform one action at a time, which is only true for slow characters. Fast characters can have multiple actions in a round that are performed simultaneously. And performing Block and Strike actions simultaneous is a totally different type of action from full defense; it is more akin to the standard attack action in other games.

Next, I shall list some of the reasons why a classic full defense action, despite being a “losing” combat maneuver, can be effective and desirable in a variety of specialized tactical situations. These situations are typically the primary mechanical reason for including a full defense action in a game.

1. The most obvious situation is when you are under attack and you are unable or unwilling to counter attack or escape, so all you can do is try to wait things out. Perhaps you are trying to survive while you reason with a violent opponent, or you're waiting for someone who has gone berserk to calm down and regain their reason, or intangible poltergeists are throwing things at you and there is no other action you can take.
In many game rules, if you are trying to escape, you are better off spending your entire round moving rather than attempting a full defense action. But in games where you can't substitute your attack action for increased movement, a character who is trying to escape will instead want to substitute his attack action for a full defense action. And if the full defense bonus is very large, it may be better to move more slowly and have an extremely strong defense.

2. You are temporarily unable to attack due to the tactical situation. For instance, in fourth edition D&D, if you are immobilized and you have no ranged attacks, you may find it worthwhile to go on total defense until you are allowed to move and attack again.

3. To wear down an opponent with expendable resources. If the enemy is throwing one use attacks at you, or they are expending endurance at a rapid rate, you may wish to use full defense, knowing that you will have an advantage later in the fight when your opponent has expended his abilities and you have not.
The opposite of this is when you have a powerful maneuver of your own which you have expended, and you are buying time to recharge it.

4. To tie down a very powerful opponent. If you are attacked by an opponent who is much more powerful than you, it might be worthwhile to go on full defense and try to survive long enough for your allies to finish up what the other enemies and come help you out. The idea is that if the opponent's actions are more effective than your own actions, it is beneficial for you to perform a full defense which costs both of you a large portion of your effectiveness. The key to this, and some of the following reasons, is that even though you pay a cost for full defense (the fact that you can still take damage and your target can’t), if the reduction in the effectiveness of the enemy’s action is more significant than the lose of your entire action, you come out ahead.
Some similar to this is the situation in which you have temporarily got yourself in a bad matchup with an opponent you cannot handle, and you need to wait for your allies to come rescue you.

5. If you simply outnumber the opponents, losing actions costs your site a lot less proportionately than it costs the other side, so if you know exactly who they're going to attack, it can be worthwhile to have those people perform full defense while everyone else smashes the enemies at full strength.

6. When you are personally outnumbered, and you can perform a single full defense action against all of the enemy attacks, it may be favorable in terms of action balance for you to sacrifice some actions in order to make a much larger number of enemy attack actions less effective.

7. If you are simply waiting for a certain event to occur, an event which will either end the fight or make you much more powerful, then you have a vested interest in making the fight go longer and you may be interested in taking full defense. Whether you actually do may depend on whether it is more effective to use full defense or to attack the enemies in order to reduce their numbers and thus the amount of damage they cause.

8. If your character has very strong passive abilities and very little attack ability, you may wish to take full defense just so that you can survive long enough to gain the full benefit of your passive abilities, since your attack abilities don't matter much anyway. For instance, if you are playing the “coach” and all you do is give tactical bonuses to the other characters.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Analysis – Let it Ride rule from the Burning Wheel

In the roleplaying game the Burning Wheel, there is a rule called “Let it Ride” that states that when you have a lengthy, multipart task which requires a certain skill, you should only have to roll the skill check once, and that skill roll is applied to every part of the extended task. Today I’m analyzing this rule and the context behind it.

On the positive side, I can totally see where this rule is coming from. The author mentions that it is directed against the concept of “roll until you fail.” This is a good way of putting it, I have experienced and hated that very same problem myself.

The problem here involves lengthy skill uses which take up considerable "screen time" and involve many sub-elements. For instance, trying to sneak into an enemy base involves sneaking past many areas with sentries or other dangers. Each time, there is logically a chance that the character would be spotted. Indeed, in the movie, there would be a bit of suspense as the character tries to sneak past each individual area where he might be spotted. So it is probably natural for the GM to want to call for a stealth skill check each time the character does something that risks getting spotted.

Unfortunately, when combined with the ordinary skill check rules used in a normal role-playing game, this can easily go disastrously wrong.

The main problem stems from the fact that the probabilities assigned to a skill check usually assume that the check will only be performed once. The GM is expected to determine a difficulty rating according to how hard the check seems to be. So a highly skilled character might have a 70% chance of succeeding in a "hard" skill check, for instance. This is okay when the hard skill check is to quickly repair a badly damaged sports car; since the individual steps aren't very interesting and quite possibly would occur "off-screen", the GM would probably call for one check and see if it succeeds or fails. But in the example of sneaking into the enemy base, the GM might decide it seems like a hard thing to do, and call for 6 hard skill rolls. But this disregards the fact that since failure in any of those roles of essentially means total failure, you have to succeed all 6 times, and that is much much harder than succeeding once. Now your chance of success is only 12% instead of 70%.

Not only is this excessively difficult, but the whole process is very arbitrary. The difficulty of the task ends up depending on how many sub-tasks the GM decides to split it into, and there is no telling how many of these there will be. This can even mean that if the player is good at role-playing and describes his actions in a more thorough and interesting fashion, the GM will think of more opportunities to call for skill checks, and the chance of succeeding will drop. Not much fun at all. I can recall playing games where you just knew there was no way the GM would allow you to succeed in a multi-part self check, even though the GM probably wasn't aware that this was what he was doing.

Even if the GM is fully aware of this problem, however, and wants to make the individual rolls easier, there are further issues. Unless the GM has considerable mathematical sophistication, determining how much easier to make the individual rolls is difficult. After all, there are no guidelines in the game for how to adjust difficulties based on number of rolls required for the check. It would be all too easy to over compensate or under compensate. Especially when you may not be sure how many rolls you are going to end up requiring beforehand. Also, the kind of adjustments required would depend upon the type of dice rolling used in the game.

Trying to convert to making numerous skill checks with a tiny chance of failure is just awkward. There isn't a lot of granularity. If you are making skill checks on d20, for instance, the chance of rolling 3+ 6 times in a row is 53%. Improving the skill check to 2+ increases the odds to 74%. And the next step up is 100%. This means that there is no way to map the many different success probabilities the characters might have on their skills; whether your normal chance of success is 8+ or 5+, the closest you can get to the same probability when rolling 6 times is 2+ either way. You certainly can't easily use a formula like add +6 to your skill bonus, as small variations in skill bonus or difficulty number would mean major changes to the overall chance of success.

But getting the odds correct still leaves a further problem. Rolling many checks, each of which has only a small chance of failure, is not necessarily as exciting as one might like. Rolling a d20, and trying to get 3+, means that a roll of 3 and a roll of 19 are pretty much the same thing. It feels odd, like you aren't really demonstrating your skill, but rather rolling dice to see if your character screws up. When you're rolling for tiny sub tasks, it is hollow to succeed extremely well in one sub task when failure in the remaining sub tasks are just as likely to make it a totally moot point. While if you “Let it Ride” and let one skill roll cover the entire task, it is much easier for the GM to interpret the overall quality of the roll in determining the amount of success you achieve.

For all of these reasons, I think the “Let it Ride” rule is a considerable improvement over the alternative of “roll until you fail”. My only complaint is that I still feel it is pretty far from the optimum rule for complex skill uses. It goes too far the other way. When you have a multi-part skill check with many possible points of failure, you either fail right up front or not at all. As I mentioned earlier, in an actual movie or book every point of failure would be a point of suspense, and you can never be sure whether the entire operation will succeed, or if not, at what point it will fail. But when one skill roll covers everything, once you succeeded in one task, you automatically succeed in every subsequent task – not very dramatic. Of course the difficulty could increase, but if you fail the check because of this, you may feel less like you failed and more like the GM suddenly pulled a dirty trick on you. Of course, the GM could have every task become more difficult than the last, but that means the GM is really “cooking” the adventure in a very specific way. And that it runs head-on into another problem, which is that if you know your roll is low or high to begin with, you can take advantage of this in illogical ways - retreating because you know you are bound to fail the next check, or taking all sorts of extra risks because you know your roll is so high you can't fail.

I think the best solution to this kind of thing is a much more elaborate system for resolving complex “skill challenges”, something like the superb Dramatic Skill Resolution system in Torg. Indeed, the Burning Wheel itself has a very simple version of such a system. But this is a difficult area in which the state-of-the-art in game design is still under development, I don't think any existing skill system I know of would really hit the “multi-part infiltration” scenario totally on the head.

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Game Rule Goals, part 3

Continuing my discussion of the various possible goals of game rules. The truth is, the goals which I've really thought about and considered for a long time and wanted to describe are those of realism, genre simulation, and entertaining game mechanics. But as I started writing this series of articles, I felt I needed to try to give fair coverage to the goals of games which seem to be trying to meet goals which were not one of these 3.

The next possible goal of a game rule or game mechanic is novelty. One of the reasons to create a new game mechanic for a game, rather than reusing a game mechanic used in older games, above and beyond any specific benefits the new rule might be trying to achieve, is just the fact that the game mechanic is interesting purely because it is new and distinctive. Making your game seem new and distinctive could be valuable in marketing a game.

Another aspect of game rules is consistency with other rules. I'm not sure whether I should classify this as a goal or a constraint, in fact I'm not sure I've made a good distinction between the two. It is a generally good thing in games to make elegant and consistent game rules. But it certainly comes to mind that I've seen games which place an extremely high value on the goal of "universality", of making sure that every possible situation is covered by an extension of the basic universal game rules, with as little possible modification of these rules to fit the specific situation. The idea of having some universal rules that cover everything might seem similar to a minimalist approach, but the examples I'm thinking of are quite different. In the old game DC Heroes, practically every object or situation was giving a measurement in terms of AP’s. In many cases this seemed unnatural and made the corresponding rule seem more complex and harder to follow. But ensured that every situation could be described in a way that it was covered by the basic universal rules of AP’s.

Finally, while I’m on the subject of purposes of rules, one of my favorites is game balance. Certainly when I make game rules, game balance might not be the overall purpose of the game, but many of individual rules have the purpose of making sure the various aspects of the game are correctly balanced with each other, with no options that are excessively good or bad.

So in summary, the game rule goals I've covered are:

1. Realism
2. Genre Simulation
3. Self Simulation
4. Entertaining Game Mechanics
5. Minimalism
6. Atmospheric Game Mechanics
7. Novelty
8. Universality
9. Game Balance

I don’t really claim to be putting together a conclusive list here, and my criteria haven’t really been rigorously thought out, but I wanted to put some ideas up for discussion and refinement.

Now, my own great passion is for making game rules with the goal of genre simulation, with a secondary focus on making entertaining game mechanics and maintaining game balance.

What I often find interesting is the interplay between the various goals. When trying to make a perfect game, the “simulation” goals (realism, genre simulation, and self-simulation) are somewhat exclusive - you need to decide what it is you are trying to simulate, if reality and fantasy work differently you can't simulate both at the same time. But genre simulation, entertaining game mechanics, and game balance are things I would all want at the same time, but in many cases it is very difficult to make a rule which optimizes one goal without interfering with other goals.

For instance, I think fourth edition Dungeons & Dragons has really ramped up the entertaining game mechanics and game balance, but at some cost in terms of believability (the simulation aspect). For instance, consider the paralyzing touch of a ghoul. It is very difficult to create a convincing mental picture of why a partially paralyzed character is unable to move from his space but maintains his full agility and combat prowess. But it sure is a whole lot more fun for the player than having his character rendered totally helpless for the entire combat. I think it was overall a good change, but I'm still tempted to think that, ultimately, I'd like to create a rule that is also fun and balanced, but which makes more sense as part of a fantasy story.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Level progression balance discrepancy - statistic bonuses

In my previous article, I described the impressive way in which the level progression in fourth edition Dungeons & Dragons has been balanced such that character abilities retain more or less the same balance relative to each other as the characters gain levels. In general, attack, defense, damage, and skills all go up at the right rate to remain generally in proportion as the characters gain levels, and prevent high-level characters from becoming progressively more polarized. However, there is one major discrepancy in this system - the fact that character statistics do not go up at the same rate. This creates a number of discrepancies as the characters gain levels.

1. Each character build has certain primary and secondary statistics needed for the class. Many of the builds, and the suggestions for those bills, imply that you would want to concentrate on 3 statistics. However, this makes no sense as far as level progression is concerned because you can only increase 2 of your statistics at the maximum rate. Of course, it is possible to divide your statistic increases between 3 statistics. But the problem with this is that you will fall farther and farther behind a character who divides his statistic increases between only 2 statistics. Primary statistics are used to calculate your attack bonus, so it is absolute essential that they be increased at a maximum rate to comply with the mathematics of the game. Otherwise, you will become less accurate than the other characters as you gain levels. This is why the idea of a character class with 2 primary statistics and a secondary statistic, like a paladin, just doesn't work. It is relatively feasible (if not optimal) to make such a character at low levels, but as the character increases in levels, one of those statistics has to be left behind or the character has to become less and less powerful compared to the other characters. Some secondary statistics are not quite as critical, affecting only things like damage or healing or other things that are not as sensitive to single points. In this case, it would be more feasible to have a character with one primary statistic that splits his points between 2 secondary statistics. However, this isn't very tempting and still results in a character who, at high levels, won't be quite as appealing as his 2 statistic counterparts.

Once you realize this is the case, you can banish the idea of 3-statistic characters from your mind and concentrate on 2-statistic characters, which work properly. However, it remains peculiar that the game tempts you to build multi-statistic characters because they appear to work okay low-level, but you have to rethink your design once you discover they don't quite translate properly at higher levels.

2. The most significant level progression imbalance is with the skill system. Fourth edition gets rid of skill points in favor of fixed bonuses for training in the skill and universal bonuses to all skills according to the level of the character. This design promises to prevent huge discrepancies in skills between the characters at high levels, and in general provide the benefits that I described in my previous blog article. However, the fact that the statistics increase at an uneven rate disrupts the symmetry. At low level, the skill system allows just about everyone to participate in skill checks whether they are skilled or unskilled. And a character who takes skill training in a skill governed by a statistic is not especially good in, still has a pretty good chance of having the best skill roll in the party if no one else took that skill. But at high levels, each character will have 2 statistics that are much higher than the others, and the skills controlled by the statistics will start to get much bigger bonuses. Now the characters who are trained in skills that match their statistics far outshine every other character. Not only does this mean that the balance of the game changes at high levels, it has effect that which class/build you have taken has more effect on your skills and which skills you are trained in. This is an effect I always disliked in games, where the streetwise fighter is forced to be less streetwise than the otherworldly fey warlock, regardless of the background stories and options chosen in character generation.

3. There are some other small effects which diverge in ways similar to the first 2 points. For instance, characters with Dex or Con bonuses gain more of a relative initiative / healing surge bonus compared to the rest of the party as they gain levels. So an infernal warlock may have fewer healing surges than a paladin at low level, but more at high level. This isn't really fatal, but it doesn't quite fit the symmetry of the uniform level progression idea. Also, there are some situations where characters make attacks which don't use primary statistics, such as longbow attacks from melee characters. At low levels these may be at least somewhat effective, but at high levels that will become less and less effective compared to the main attack to the point of uselessness.

So the next question is, what would you do if you decided you wanted to fix this imbalance? Well, a very straightforward way to do so would be to have every statistic increase every 4 levels instead of just 2 statistics increasing every 4 levels. This would have a significant advantage of fixing the problems listed above. I should also note that it would make all sorts of unusual multi-class combinations possible and fun. However, it would also carry some potential disadvantages:

1. As mentioned above, primary and secondary statistics often have effects where the same amount of bonus is just as good at high-level is a low level. I think a good word to capture this is that some bonuses are "logarithmic". A 2-point bonus to attack or defense is just as good for a high-level character with a +30 attack as it is for a local character with a +4 attack. Other benefits are non-logarithmic. A +2 damage bonus for a high-level character who does about 22 points of damage is much less effective than the same bonus for a low-level character who does about 8 points of damage.

If every statistic increased at the same rate, then for non-logarithmic abilities controlled by secondary statistics, the actual value of your statistic would mean less and less as you gain level. That is, at low level, a barbarian with a relatively high constitution might gain 3 temporary hit points when he defeated a foe, while barbarian who had basically ignored constitution might only gain 1 temporary hit point, a big difference. But at high-level, it might be the difference between 8 temporary hit points and 6 temporary hit points, not a big deal. So in this case, having all of the statistics increase at the same rate would cause some abilities to scale less well with level. I think this would be the major disadvantage of allowing every statistic to increase.

Although this definitely causes some problems with the scaling, some of the other effects it has on the game might be good or bad. It would mean that at high-level, classes with 2 secondary statistics would now find it very practical to take powers relying on their lesser secondary statistic. My general impression is that such powers are normally much less tempting to take then the flavor of the game would indicate (in particular, they seem to imply that you should take some of these powers when they describe the class builds, but I find it quite difficult to ever want to take a power which is based on a secondary statistic that I am not improving, unless the power is really broken to begin with). So feeling more free to take these powers might be a good thing. Or maybe not, I can't really say.

2. With constitution increasing at a faster rate, high-level parties would have noticeably more healing surges than low-level parties. Since they have noticeably more healing powers, I don't know whether this is a good or bad thing.

3. Many feats have prerequisites that prevent certain class builds from getting those feats. With every statistic increasing, pretty much every build would eventually be able to get most feats. If those statistic minimums were carefully designed and considered as part of the class balance (it isn't clear whether this is true), this might mean the class balance is disrupted somewhat. For instance, normally only fighters who invest in high Dex scores can take scale armor specialization, but now even Con-based axe fighters could do so.

4. I would expect that a major actual reason that not all statistics are made to increase with level is a combination of inertia/tradition (only one statistic increased with level in third edition, and none before that), and the idea that it is fun getting to choose where your statistic points to go with levels. It is true that there is a small amount of discretion in the way you allocate your statistic bonuses, it is sometimes possible to make little trade-offs, not increasing a secondary statistic in order to raise constitution or a statistic necessary to qualify for a feat. But in general, the game balance so strongly demands that you increase the 2 statistics associated with your class build, that I haven't found getting to choose where your statistic bonuses go to be a particularly interesting process in practice.

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Balanced Level Progression

A very impressive feature of fourth edition Dungeons & Dragons is that the level progression has been balanced so that, on average, the various capabilities of players and monsters go up at the same rate as levels are gained.

In previous editions of Dungeons & Dragons, the distinctions between the various characters and classes started out at a fairly modest level, but grew greater and greater at higher and higher levels. For instance, at low levels a fighter had only a small “to hit” advantage over a cleric with the same strength. But as the fighter gained levels, the fighters hit advantage would become greater and greater compared to the cleric. And previous to third edition, the fighter would gain multiple attacks at a certain point, and the cleric never would. Of course, this was balanced out by the fact that at low levels the cleric spells were not all that amazing compared to the natural fighting ability of the classes, whereas at high levels they grew disproportionately and became massively powerful. However, the point is that at low levels the cleric could be a "secondary fighter" who didn't fight as well as the fighter, but fought decently. On the other hand, the cleric could have some pretty useful spells, but couldn't really concentrate on being a major spellcaster, he had to do a lot of conventional fighting. But at higher levels, the cleric’s fighting ability would become less and less important, and the spell ability more and more important. In other words, the essential purpose and style of different classes and characters would vary continuously as levels were gained. In theory, there is nothing intrinsically wrong with this. In practice, however, it made the game very difficult to design and balance correctly. Typically there would be a “sweet spot” level where the relative capabilities of the 2 classes felt about right, and the farther you were above or below this level, the less well the game seemed to work.

This issue of gains in levels changing the essential balance of the game occurred in many other places as well. For instance, in third edition you earned skill points every level, and it was possible to put the maximum number of skill points into one skill, or to divide up your skill points more evenly. Dividing them up worked interestingly at low level, but at high level it would mean that you were so far behind someone who had maxed out the skill that the GM practically couldn't design an adventure which would challenge one skill level without being either impossible or trivial for the other skill level. And it meant that at low level, an ordinary character might notice a stealthy opponent, but at high level, a character class which didn’t specialize in perception was practically blind against a stealthy opponent.

Designing the hit bonuses and defenses of monsters was also tricky, since with a d20 system it is important for the values to fall within a narrow range in order to prevent the rolls from becoming trivial or impossible, but when the characters diverge at higher levels is soon becomes impossible for maintain this balance. You don’t want characters to hit on 2’s or only hit on 20’s, but when hit bonuses diverge tremendously you can’t cover everyone.

Note that the fact that fighters got more hit points per level than clerics was not an example of this sort of divergence. If a fighter starts with, say, 50% more hit points than the cleric, and gains 50% more hit points than the cleric does every level, the fighter will always have 50% more hit points than the cleric. So for game design purposes, the relative abilities of the fighter and the cleric in this regard stay constant, even though both are becoming more and more powerful. But if the fighter hits in melee combat 20% more often the cleric at low level, but at high level he hits 80% more often and gets twice as many attacks, then his power relative to the cleric has tripled at high levels, drastically changing the nature of the relationship between fighters and clerics.

Fourth edition Dungeons & Dragons tries to solve this problem by having the capabilities of the characters improve at a uniform rate such that the characters remain more or less in balance compared to each other. I think this works really really well and is a great idea. Classes of all kinds get new powers, feats, magic item bonuses, skill bonuses, and attack and defense bonuses at the same rate. And this rate is carefully calculated to be equal to the rate at which the monsters improve. Some of my previous articles have noted some small discrepancies in his calculations, but in effect these mistakes are the "exception that proves the rule". That is, the fact that small discrepancies are actually noticeable and worthy of correction shows the extent to which the game has been balanced; such small differences would be lost among the vast disparities in powers and abilities between the classes in previous editions.

Now, the relative stability in capabilities between the classes as levels progress is not going to be 100% perfect. Since players have flexibility in what feats, paragon paths, and epic destinies they take, and in what magic items they discover, the various characters are likely to become more different from each other at higher levels just because they have more choice available. But this is no big deal, it isn't a system of inevitably increasing disparity with level. Whenever I see an ability that changes disproportionately with level (that is, becomes less effective or more effective than other comparable abilities as the character level changes), I call that out as a deviation from the normal level progression balance. In most cases, such deviations detract from the game, as the ability will be "just right" at some levels, and too weak or too strong at others.

A good practical example of this is the way that attack and damage bonuses work. A bonus of +1 to hit is equally valuable at all levels, because the increase in monster defenses means that your base chance to hit monsters of your level should stay the same as you gain levels. But a bonus of +1 to damage becomes less useful at higher levels, because the total damage you are doing is higher and thus the additional one point of damage is a smaller percentage increase in your damage output. Therefore, in order for a damage bonus to not become ineffective as you gain levels, the damage bonus needs to increase with every level you gain. This is also true with hit point bonuses. But with attack and defense bonuses, they need to stay the same, otherwise they become overly effective as you gain levels.

This is why the bonus from weapon focus increases with every tier; it has to increase in order to stay equally effective relative to the character. The fact that the damage bonus from Dwarf Weapon Training is a fixed +2 bonus means that it does not retain its usefulness at high levels.. It means that dwarves are incredibly potent with axes and hammers at low level, but lose a lot of this advantage at high levels.

On the other hand, the fact that the new Weapon Expertise feats give you increasing hit bonuses at higher levels means they increase in power at a disproportionate rate. At low level they are very useful, at high levels they are absolutely incredible and indispensable. This would be broken if it wasn't clear that these feats were meant as mathematical fixes rather than legitimate optional feats.

The idea that attack bonuses should not increase with level and damage bonuses should is a corollary of the underlying game system and seems to have been fairly well followed by the designers of features and powers, although there are a few mistakes. For instance, the fact that the wizard’s orb feature gives an ever increasing penalty to saving throws as the wizards level increases, despite the fact a penalty to saving throws, like just about anything else rolled on the d20, does not need to and should not increase as you gain levels.

I'm not going into examples of this right now. But there is one major area in which the game's wonderfully balanced level progression is disrupted at a more fundamental level; I shall describe this next week.